Pages

Thursday, October 7, 2010

Money, Money, Money, Muuuuneeee - Inflation, Deflation and Gold

The Deep Cause of the Great Financial Crisis


by Antal Fekete


The Great Depression of the 1930’s, in particular, the unprecedented world-wide unemployment was caused by the decision of the victorious Entente powers to return to the gold standard after World War I, BUT without allowing the clearing house of the gold standard, the international bill market, to make a comeback....

...This decision was made in secret. It has never been made public. But there can be no doubt about the fact that in 1920 everybody, even Keynes himself, admitted the desirability of an expeditious return to the gold standard. Had there been no decision to ban it, bill trading would have started spontaneously...

...World trade prior to 1914 was multilateral. By this I mean that imports were paid for by issuing, endorsing, and accepting bills of exchange payable in gold at maturity no more than 91 days after shipping the underlying merchandise. With three good signatures: that of the exporter, that of the importer, and that of a recognized acceptor the bill of exchange went through a most remarkable metamorphosis. It became money. Ephemeral, to be sure, but money nevertheless. The exporter could use it to pay for his imports by passing it on, after endorsing it, to the exporter in a third country. This exporter could likewise use it to pay for his own imports, and so on and so forth. Only in the light of this fact can one explain the unprecedented expansion of world trade during the 100-year period between 1815, marking the end of the Napoleonic War and 1914, marking the outbreak of World War I. Such a record level of world trade would not have been possible without the clearing house for the gold standard, the bill market. Geographically, this clearing house was located in the City of London. It was the great London trading houses and banks on which bills of exchange, covering merchandise shipped from country A to country B, were drawn. It was the great acceptance houses in London that accepted them. Once so endorsed and accepted, these bills started to circulate on their own wings and under their own power, as only monetary gold could circulate: without friction...

...The destruction of the Wage Fund was not immediately noticed. The great inflation due to World War I imparted sufficient stimulus for a full decade to cover up the complete absence of a reliable fund out of which wages could be paid. In due course, however, the surplus money was siphoned off by an extraordinary explosion of speculative activity in financial bills, real estate, and in the shares of joint-stock companies. Real bills were conspicuous only by their absence...

...When money became scarce after the bubbles burst one after another: the bubble in US Treasury bonds in 1920, the Florida real estate bubble in 1925, and the stock market bubble in 1929, the absence of the Wage Fund, destroyed a decade earlier, immediately became obvious. There was no money to pay the wage earner. Workers were laid off. They had to be put on the dole. An unprecedented wave of unemployment, like a tsunami, engulfed the world. Dictatorships could escape the curse of unemployment by destroying civil liberties: Lenin’s under the banner of international socialism, Hitler’s under the banner of national socialism....


...History may not be repeating, but it certainly is strongly echoing itself. The Great Financial Crisis of 2008 is such an echo of the Great Depression of 1930. Or could it be that the Great Depression of 1930 was the harbinger of something far worse: the Great Financial Crisis of 2008 and its aftermath, still to be visited upon the world?...

...The last remnants of the gold standard were abolished in 1971 when the Republican president Richard Nixon defaulted on the international gold obligations of the US — almost 40 years after the Democratic president Franklin D. Roosevelt defaulted on its domestic gold obligations. It triggered the fast-breeder of money, originally envisaged by Keynes, later dressed up academically and made palatable politically by Milton Friedman. At first, the going was great under the catch-word: “you have never had it so good”. But then, just as during the “roaring 20’s”, speculators grabbed the money spun out by the fast breeders and ran with it. Once again, bubbles were blown and started bursting one after another. Now the world is confronted with the worst prospects for unemployment ever...

...At any rate, far worse than the one Rittershausen had predicted in 1930. We can, using his methodology, predict Great Depression II in the making. The world still is lacking a Wage Fund. A vastly expanded army of unemployed people will have to be fed, clad, shod and sheltered. The money to do it is not there. Once again, governments will have to create it out of nothing to pay the dole...

...The way to return to the gold standard is for the US government to open the US Mint to gold — as ordained by the American Constitution that has been violated by power-hungry presidents such F. D. Roosevelt and his successors, every one of whom swore to uphold it, only to turn around and trample on it...

...It would be an extraordinary act of statesmanship if a new president reinstated the monetary provisions of the American Constitution.

There is no other way to prevent the collapse of the debt tower, or to fend off the tsunami of unemployment and the global breakdown of law and order...


Anatal Fekete refers to this - The Inverted Golden Pyramid -  the hierarchy of "money" - the good stuff at the bottom...the shaky stuff at the top








http://www.financialsense.com/contributors/antal-fekete/the-deep-cause-of-the-great-financial-crisis

9 comments:

  1. Ah, a return to the gold standard. Mssr. Prechter and the late Mssr. Elliott are most pleased. Giddy cynicism aside whether one prefers an economy based on fiat money or the gold standard I readily agree with Prof. Fekete’s comment:

    ...History may not be repeating, but it certainly is strongly echoing itself. The Great Financial Crisis of 2008 is such an echo of the Great Depression of 1930. Or could it be that the Great Depression of 1930 was the harbinger of something far worse: the Great Financial Crisis of 2008 and its aftermath, still to be visited upon the world?

    The sequelae to the current Great Financial Crisis have yet to fully appear but if one subscribes to historical precedent arguably the most effective solution to these outcomes will be apocalyptic in scope. The Second World War was the necessary although certainly unintended answer for the Great Depression.

    It can be argued that we are facing an even more difficult environment than what existed pre-WW II: a superpower at war with much more challenging enemies than the usual 1939 suspects, a global economic crisis which threatens to further deteriorate and take more hostages, an expanding coterie of nations addicted to fossil fuels and necessarily supportive of or at least acquiescent to dictatorial supplier nations, an ever widening divide between the haves and the have-nots and global warning and potential pandemics in the offing.

    So what can we do? I don’t know about you but I need to return to my man cave and watch some baseball.

    ReplyDelete
  2. prof fekete certainly is a proponent of the gold standard...we are 40 years into the fiat experiment and we are wobbling...will we have a sovereign debt crisis? will the dollar go the way of all fiat currencies?

    prechter is in the deflation camp big time - deflation first, inflation second...helicopter ben has clearly stated the goal of his mission, and that is to avoid another great depression at all cost - drop money from helicopters, QE2 infinity...

    commodity prices are rising, the dollar has resumed its move south...

    it is a widely held, but a quite questionable belief, that WWII got us out of the great depression, it certainly got people out of being unemployed (what was it 25% unemployment?), although the employment was largely into the military to fight the wretched fight...how many died in WWII?

    ...don't simply take the blue pill and return to your man cave - take the red pill and convert that useless paper in your pocket into some gold, oil, and rare earths...

    ReplyDelete
  3. I love it.
    Gray found his way down the rabbit hole. Welcome.
    "No wonder you're late. Why, this watch is exactly two days slow."
    Mad Hatter
    Its great to have some thoughtful banter to liven up the exchange and challenge Wes with some engaging comments. Someone in the forest to hear the tree fall.

    As far as the socioeconomic drama that's playing out I must say, as interesting as it is, it's well above my pay grade. And as an architect I am not very comfortable with an inverted pyramid, too much load concentrated to a single point. Inherently unstable.

    "Let me see: four times five is twelve, and four times six is thirteen, and four times seven is -- oh dear! I shall never get to twenty at that rate!" Alice

    Go Braves!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Also as an architect placing value on use and utility I think I'd be inclined to hedge by investing in Copper.

    Oct. 6 (Bloomberg) -- Gold prices may surge 64 percent and copper will jump to the highest level ever as the dollar tumbles, said Mari Kooi, the chief executive officer of Wolf Asset Management International LLC.
    Although I find the range in values interesting; Gold at $2,200 an once , Copper at $8,200 a ton.

    ReplyDelete
  5. You're spot on regarding WWII and the Great Depression. I didn't mean to imply that the war and its accompanying atrocities were a priori reasons for the end of the GD. More accurately a systemic and profoundly horrific series of events were neccesary to finally galvanize public and private cooperation and action.

    I think this is what Ferete was intimating. Nonetheless I did venture out of my man cave (after the Yankees won) and re-read the latest EWFF. I respect much of Prechter's analyses but for individual investors I find it's much less valuable given Prechter's timing errors...weren't we supposed to have seen a DJIA <4000 by now? Timing aside Preacher's and Ferete's trumpeting of a return to the gold standard has a lot merit and is worthly of serious examination.

    What would John Galt think??

    ReplyDelete
  6. @FE - you got the idea of the inverted pyramid - "inherently unstable" indeed...now look at the elements constituting the pyramid, from the top down...that is all the money and credit in the world from bad to money good...

    ReplyDelete
  7. @Gray - i find it intriguing to find that you are a reader/follower of the Elliott Wave forecasts of Prechter and co...

    ...do you use this information of entertainment value, estate planning, day trading?

    i like to hear what prechter was to say, to expand my range of thinking about possible outcomes in the economy and markets...as opposed to use him for market timing, although he has made some good market timing calls, if not early...he pretty well called the march '09 bottom, and called to get out early, if i recall it was nov '09, which left another 20% on the table, but captured 50% of the rise...

    we have a number of prechter references at RPBP - i think his socionomics theory is particular interesting, especially from a contrarian viewpoint...waves of optimism and pessimism...but, then again, say "WAVES" and i'm all in...

    http://red-pill-blue-pill.blogspot.com/2010/09/bob-prechter-of-elliott-wave.html

    http://red-pill-blue-pill.blogspot.com/2010/09/fibo-phi-618-baby.html

    http://www.robertprechter.com/?page_id=83

    ReplyDelete
  8. Wes-

    I read Prechter mainly for his socionomics theory. IMHO socionomics is largely ignored or discredited by many of the "leading" economists. As someone who had just enough economics training (BA Economics)to be dangerous I abhor the almost unconditional belief by professional economists in quant modeling and commitment to econometrics.

    Don't get me wrong, mathematical analyses are extremely important but they fundamental fail (or are unable) to address the human influence on economies. Exhibit A is the Great Recession although I will concede there were some contrarians in the years leading up to the crisis.

    What surpised me about the GR was the inability (denial?) of the leading quants and their corporate guardians and economists to fully appreciate what was happening. One thing was made clear: never underestimate the complete elasticity of human greed.

    ReplyDelete
  9. ...cool, i have been getting into the socionomics concept more and more over the last year or so...

    ...regarding The GR, there are a lot of folks who saw it coming and said so, and some of us were even prepared...but, timing is difficult, probably due to the elasticity to which you refer...we are now simply in the eye of the storm...keep your guard up...

    ...i like to blame the Fed and Alan (Easy AL, Bubbles) Greenspan for holding interest rates so low in response to every economic set back and fueling a sequence of bubbles - Tech Stocks, Housing, now Treasuries, even wall street called it the Greenspan Put - however, as a follower of Socionomics, you are probably aware of Prechter's graph showing the Fed Funds Rate changes lagging Treasury rate changes - hence, reacting to the "social" mood not leading it...I see Bob is calling for Dow 1000 still, plunge in Gold, and a reversal and strengthening of the USD...i guess the former two events would be consistent with the last...

    ReplyDelete